Threaded Mode | Linear Mode

muslim girl · 03-04-2010, 07:31 PM

After thinking I think that killing apostate is not a law in Islam
Because the messenger accept it to be intercede
And there is no verse a bout killing
And the Hadeeth ask to kill people who "The leaver's religion. Junctions of the group"
And that means who transfer from Islam and become traitor
There is one a problem with one Hadeeth
"Who change his religion kill him"
I search a lot about this Hadeeth which does not contain the condition of being traitor like others
But who transfer this Hadeeth do not mention its storey
So it is not clear at all
People who convert to Islam are changing their religion
However if the prophet accept Intercede in that
That means for sure that is not a law
Bin hazem Andalusia has that opinion
He explain that in his book
al_mahali
If any Arabic wants to read I do not think it have a translation

muslim girl · 03-04-2010, 08:34 PM

I think that maybe it will be useful to tell you that there are conditions to cut the thief hand
First he should sue you
Second: to be thing with economical value
That means more it worth more than 1.0625 gram of gold (which is 24th kind can we express it like that in English)
Third: what he stole should have been saved well before the stealing process or there will be no cutting
Forth: if he stole any thing there is no cutting
Fifth: if there was famine no cutting

Islam=True · 04-20-2010, 02:41 PM

(03-04-2010 07:31 PM)muslim girl Wrote: After thinking I think that killing apostate is not a law in Islam
Because the messenger accept it to be intercede
And there is no verse a bout killing
And the Hadeeth ask to kill people who "The leaver's religion. Junctions of the group"
And that means who transfer from Islam and become traitor
There is one a problem with one Hadeeth
"Who change his religion kill him"
I search a lot about this Hadeeth which does not contain the condition of being traitor like others
But who transfer this Hadeeth do not mention its storey
So it is not clear at all
People who convert to Islam are changing their religion
However if the prophet accept Intercede in that
That means for sure that is not a law
Bin hazem Andalusia has that opinion
He explain that in his book
al_mahali
If any Arabic wants to read I do not think it have a translation

There is no Problem with the hadith sister its from the prophets and companions don't say that ever again please Smile

kevlar · 04-20-2010, 02:46 PM

Islam=True

Quote:There is no Problem with the hadith sister its from the prophets and companions don't say that ever again please

Don't come on these boards and threaten a longstanding member. Or you can just go away.

Islam=True · 04-20-2010, 04:36 PM

(04-20-2010 02:46 PM)kevlar Wrote: Islam=True

Quote:There is no Problem with the hadith sister its from the prophets and companions don't say that ever again please
Don't come on these boards and threaten a longstanding member. Or you can just go away.

She is saying something wrong about my religion i gotta stand up and correct her..... No ones threatening her shes my sister i don't want her to be misguided Smile

Jazakhallah